This eyeliner has the nicest APPLICATOR. Felt-tip and thin, perfect for a quick winged liner. I used to be amazed by how quickly it did my eyeliner in the morning. The only issue is it flakes during the day and smudges everywhere if you have oily eyelids like me. Not sure if an eyelid primer helps. The waterproof version is only slightly better but it also smudges everywhere and is decidedly NOT waterproof. Not a long-lasting product, so despite loving the applicator, I had to stop using it to avoid the raccoon-eyes/hungover look.
I've used this once before. At first, I felt like I had found the perfect product due to its thin tip. However, after a few weeks, the colour had gone lighter and the product dried up too quickly