I am still on the hunt for the perfect clump-free mascara. The task seems impossible, and although I was holding out hope for this product (I am a huge fan of Revlon), it hasn't lived up to my expectations, unfortunately. While I love the colour (I usually go with a black-brown shade to match my brown liner for day wear), I often have to scrape off the excess product at the edge of the bottle, or it ends up clumping my lashes. Not ideal. What I really want is a mascara whose wand comes out perfectly ready for application, but I'm beginning to think a mascara like that is elusive. The Lash Potion is water resistant and lasts all day, but it is somewhat difficult to remove with regular eye makeup remover.