I purchased this gel liner a while back in the shade very black.It is a very affordable gel liner and it came with a really cute brush which was an added bonus.The formula is creamy but it tends to drag on my skin when i apply it but with time i got used to it.I love that it dried to a matte finish and looked amazing although it was not an intense black that i was hoping for.The brush that it comes with is really good , it allows you to create a really fine line or even a thick line if you are going for a dramatic yet bold look.After a while i found that the gel gets a bit dry so make sure to keep the lid sealed tightly.