These really do sparkle. I bought 01 just classy its a metallic black with gold flakes it's a really beautiful color, I really
love the applicator, it's very thin but flexible to ensure you have a precise, fine line. But I have to admit the formula of this product is not great it started to flake after an hour and later I had gaps and I just rubbed my eye with my finger and it all came off which was sad. I recommend you apply this liner over an existing gel liner to add a sparkle and when it starts to flake it's not as noticeable.