I don't think Ill ever NOT give a Essence product a 5 out of 5 for price cause is just no product with such a good quality that can beat their prices!
All the shades are very creamy and apply like a dream with almost no fall-out. I did find that although the light colors are very creamy and pigmented and shimmery and the darker colors aren't that pigmented. But since Essence are very build-able after a second round its yet another shade of greatness!