I absolutely love winged eyeliner, it's my ride or die go to makeup look however it can take a bit of practicing to perfect so when I saw the long sharp tip of this liner I knew it would be perfect. It's black as night and easy to build up a good wing, what really attracted me to this liner though was that I found it quite long lasting as I swatched it on my hand and it would not budge even when I tried to rub it off its also much darker than the original pen liner which tends to look a little on the grey side. The only thing I don't like about this liner is that you have to make sure it's closed as soon as you are done as it dries super fast